Aflac’s Shift from Efficiency to Impact: 3x Lead Growth

What happens when a legacy insurance giant

What happens when a legacy insurance giant

What happens when a legacy insurance giant

year

2025

Client

Aflac

SERVICES

Paid Media

year

2025

Client

Aflac

SERVICES

Paid Media

year

2025

Client

Aflac

SERVICES

Paid Media

The Challenges

Everyone knows Aflac, yet few actually know what Aflac sells.

Despite decades of fame thanks to the Aflac Duck, few consumers actually understood Aflac’s range of insurance products. Many mistook its signature Accident Insurance for auto coverage. When Theo began working with Aflac in 2016, the brand had strong awareness through TV, radio, and sponsorships—but its digital lower funnel told a different story. It primarily targeted people already searching for Aflac, rather than those seeking the types of insurance products Aflac offered.

The Challenges

Everyone knows Aflac, yet few actually know what Aflac sells.

Despite decades of fame thanks to the Aflac Duck, few consumers actually understood Aflac’s range of insurance products. Many mistook its signature Accident Insurance for auto coverage. When Theo began working with Aflac in 2016, the brand had strong awareness through TV, radio, and sponsorships—but its digital lower funnel told a different story. It primarily targeted people already searching for Aflac, rather than those seeking the types of insurance products Aflac offered.

The Challenges

Everyone knows Aflac, yet few actually know what Aflac sells.

Despite decades of fame thanks to the Aflac Duck, few consumers actually understood Aflac’s range of insurance products. Many mistook its signature Accident Insurance for auto coverage. When Theo began working with Aflac in 2016, the brand had strong awareness through TV, radio, and sponsorships—but its digital lower funnel told a different story. It primarily targeted people already searching for Aflac, rather than those seeking the types of insurance products Aflac offered.

The Solutions

We shifted Aflac's digital strategy from brand-dependent bottom-funnel tactics to product-first prospecting. Which is to say: we stopped assuming everyone who knew the Duck understood what the Duck was selling.

Product-First Paid Search

  • Rebuilt campaigns around product keywords ("dental insurance," "short-term disability") rather than brand terms

  • Created dedicated landing pages for each product line

  • Intercepted consumers at the moment they're actually trying to solve a problem

Audience Segmentation via Machine Learning

  • Identified high-propensity prospects based on browsing behavior and similar audience modeling

  • Found people who looked like they might actually buy insurance, as opposed to people who just thought the Duck was funny

Product-Centric Creative & Remarketing

  • Developed messaging that clearly explained what each product covered and who it served

  • Retargeted users with tailored messages about the specific products they viewed

UX & Site Wayfinding Overhaul

  • Launched dedicated prospecting landing pages optimized for conversion

  • Refined self-selection paths for business vs. consumer audiences

  • A/B tested CTAs, headlines, and layouts to create a frictionless journey

  • Result: 99% of leads converting through the correct form for their segment

The Result

Tested media mix expansion toward incremental lead and revenue growth, rather than optimizing towards easy wins.

  • Activated a robust media testing roadmap focused on audience segmentation, sequential messaging and product-focused creative.

  • Enhanced the experience of core owned properties through digital optimization, experience testing and user research.

  • Integrated marketing data with Aflac's business outcomes to understand the true impact of the marketing mix.

194%

Increase in Consumer Leads

257%

Increase in B2B Sales Leads

31%

Increase in e-Commerce Sales